Who is Not Without Sin

Story MissionRed Dead Redemption 2 ✓ Checked against sources · 8/8

Type: Story Mission
Given by: Reverend Orville Swanson
Chapter: Chapter 2 (Horseshoe Overlook)
Starts: Flatneck Station in The Heartlands, New Hanover
Missable: Skipping the optional poker game inside the mission forfeits the Gold Medal requirement to win two hands
Choices: Play or Decline Poker → Choosing to play allows you to win money and work toward the gold medal objective; declining skips straight to searching for Swanson
Threaten or kill the shepherd witness → Threatening him into silence preserves Honor, while killing him results in Honor loss
Gold medal: Win 2 hands of Poker
Return Reverend Swanson to camp within 2 minutes and 5 seconds
Walkthrough: Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook

Sources: powerpyx.com, ign.com