We Loved Once and True - III

Story MissionRed Dead Redemption 2 ✓ Checked against sources · 10/10

Type: Story Mission
Given by: Mary Linton
Chapter: Chapter 2 (Horseshoe Overlook)
Starts: Cumberland Forest, New Hanover
Rewards: Positive Honor
Missable: The entire mission chain is missable and must be completed during Chapter 2
Missing or declining it prevents earning the "Lending a Hand" trophy/achievement
Choices: Dialogue with the Chelonian Master: answer peacefully ("Undecided" and "Purpose") or antagonize him → Peaceful answers let you talk to Jamie without violence, while negative answers cause Arthur to choke the Master unconscious (either way, Jamie still flees on horseback)
In the conversation preceding Part III, choose to help Mary or decline → Choosing to help Mary unlocks Part III, while declining terminates the mission line immediately
Gold medal: Peacefully convince the Chelonians to let you take Jamie
Return Jamie to Mary within 2 minutes
Walkthrough: Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook

Sources: gtabase.com, powerpyx.com, ign.com, guides4gamers.com