We Loved Once and True - II

Story MissionRed Dead Redemption 2 ✓ Checked against sources · 9/9

Arthur meets with Mary Linton at Chadwick Farm, where she asks for his assistance.

Type: Story Mission
Given by: Mary Linton
Chapter: Chapter 2
Starts: Chadwick Farm, located just north of Valentine
Missable: The mission is missable if not completed before finishing Chapter 2 / progressing too far in the story
Refusing to help Mary causes you to miss the subsequent mission ("We Loved Once and True - III")
Missing the continuation will prevent you from earning the "Lending a Hand" trophy/achievement (completing all optional Honor story missions) on that playthrough
Choices: Help → Ends Part II and unlocks "We Loved Once and True - III" to go rescue her brother Jamie
Refuse → Immediately ends the questline, skipping Part III entirely
Walkthrough: Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook

Sources: gtabase.com, guides4gamers.com, ireddead.com, rdr2.org