The Spines of America

Story MissionRed Dead Redemption 2 ✓ Checked against sources · 11/11

Type: Story Mission
Given by: Hosea Matthews
Chapter: Chapter 2 (Horseshoe Overlook)
Starts: Emerald Ranch in New Hanover
Rewards: Arthur's cut is approximately $82.50 to $84 (with the gang taking a $150 cut from the stagecoach score), plus any cash looted inside the house
General household provisions, consumables, and valuables looted from Carmody Dell
The Emerald Ranch fence run by Seamus, granting the ability to sell stolen wagons and coaches as well as fenced goods and craft talismans
Choices: Rob the house during the day → Hosea distracts Bob Crawford and his son outside by pretending to be a salesman, while Arthur sneaks inside the house
Wait until nightfall → The occupants are asleep inside the house, and Hosea sneaks into the barn to secure the stagecoach while Arthur loots the house
Gold medal: Loot everything from Carmody Dell
Don't get spotted
Deliver the wagon to Emerald Ranch within 1 minute 10 seconds
Walkthrough: Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook

Sources: gtabase.com, powerpyx.com, ign.com