Guides / Red Dead Redemption 2 / Stranger Mission

Oh, Brother

The mission strand involves twin brothers Proetus and Acrisius performing various competitive feats to progress sequentially. Every playthrough ends with the same outcome: the brothers survive Cumberland Falls, reconcile their mutual bond, and abandon Helen.

Type

Stranger Mission

Given by

The twin brothers Proetus and Acrisius

Chapter

Chapter 4

Starts

Outside the General Store in Valentine, New Hanover

Parts

Oh, Brother - I · Chapter 4

Outside the General Store in Valentine, New Hanover

1. Speak to twin brothers Proetus and Acrisius outside the general store in Valentine.
2. Follow the twins behind the building.
3. Shoot bottles off the head of each brother.
4. Shoot smaller bottles off their heads while the brothers balance on one foot.

Part II · Chapter 4

Behind the saloon/General Store area in Valentine, New Hanover

1. Wait roughly 24 in-game hours, then approach the brothers behind the Valentine saloon or general store.
2. Punch both brothers in the face when prompted.
3. Punch both brothers in the stomach.
4. Kick or hit each brother between the legs.

Part III · Chapter 4

Cumberland Falls, along the Dakota River

1. Wait another in-game day, then meet the brothers and Helen at the top of Cumberland Falls.
2. Push both brothers over the edge in wooden barrels.
3. Mount your horse and ride along the riverbank downstream with Helen.
4. Approach the twins washed up on shore.

Walkthrough

Chapter 4: Saint Denis

26 facts on this page checked against sources · 26 supported · last checked Oct 2026

Sources: rdr2.org, gtabase.com, powerpyx.com